Comments on: The Most Indispensable New York Giants http://www.giantsgab.com/2009/09/24/the-most-indispensable-new-york-giants/ The Definitive New York Giants Blog! Thu, 11 Mar 2010 04:34:42 -0600 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.6 hourly 1 By: Eli Manning’s Greatness!!!??? » Giants Gab http://www.giantsgab.com/2009/09/24/the-most-indispensable-new-york-giants/comment-page-1/#comment-10092 Eli Manning’s Greatness!!!??? » Giants Gab Sat, 26 Sep 2009 23:18:24 +0000 http://www.giantsgab.com/?p=2835#comment-10092 [...] The Ten Giants We Can’t afford to Lose. [...] [...] The Ten Giants We Can’t afford to Lose. [...]

]]> By: Jesse Bartolis http://www.giantsgab.com/2009/09/24/the-most-indispensable-new-york-giants/comment-page-1/#comment-10091 Jesse Bartolis Sat, 26 Sep 2009 23:16:21 +0000 http://www.giantsgab.com/?p=2835#comment-10091 I agree that Boss is valued mostly becuase our TE situation could get ugly in a hurry. The problem I have with Jacobs listed so high is We have won without him already. Same thing with Osi, especially Osi (12-4 last year. He's missed many other games before as well) I think I might have been too low on O'hara I can agree with you there becuase our center position is also terrible. GOOD call on Feagles. Good list. I'll still disagree with Jacobs and Osi I like the rest though.I think you swayed me on O'hara. I agree that Boss is valued mostly becuase our TE situation could get ugly in a hurry.

The problem I have with Jacobs listed so high is We have won without him already.

Same thing with Osi, especially Osi (12-4 last year. He’s missed many other games before as well)

I think I might have been too low on O’hara I can agree with you there becuase our center position is also terrible.

GOOD call on Feagles.

Good list.

I’ll still disagree with Jacobs and Osi I like the rest though.I think you swayed me on O’hara.

]]> By: Jason C. http://www.giantsgab.com/2009/09/24/the-most-indispensable-new-york-giants/comment-page-1/#comment-10088 Jason C. Fri, 25 Sep 2009 21:12:59 +0000 http://www.giantsgab.com/?p=2835#comment-10088 My top 10 1. Eli 2. Jacobs 3. Snee 4. O'Hara 5. Tuck 6. Pierce 7. Osi 8. Webster 9. Smith 10. Feagles Jacobs is CLEARLY higher of a priority than you have him listed, and Phillips is already gone so adding him to the list is just too pessimistic for my blood. Also Boss is only valued because our TE situation is so bad, I'd like to see Beckum get some play this week, especially if things get ugly early, which the Giants SHOULD be capable of pulling off... My top 10
1. Eli
2. Jacobs
3. Snee
4. O’Hara
5. Tuck
6. Pierce
7. Osi
8. Webster
9. Smith
10. Feagles

Jacobs is CLEARLY higher of a priority than you have him listed, and Phillips is already gone so adding him to the list is just too pessimistic for my blood. Also Boss is only valued because our TE situation is so bad, I’d like to see Beckum get some play this week, especially if things get ugly early, which the Giants SHOULD be capable of pulling off…

]]> By: Andrew Ilnicki http://www.giantsgab.com/2009/09/24/the-most-indispensable-new-york-giants/comment-page-1/#comment-10077 Andrew Ilnicki Fri, 25 Sep 2009 13:06:16 +0000 http://www.giantsgab.com/?p=2835#comment-10077 Frankly, I am surprised that Brandon Jacobs isn't a bit higher. I love Bradshaw but the hard hitting tone set by Jacobs is a crucial #1 in the 1-2 punch. I like seeing the GM and HC up there too, way to give credit where its due in terms of vision, discipline, and focus. Did you ever think in 2006 Eli Manning would be #1 on this list? Think about this -- in every other NFC East market Eli Manning is known as the Giants biggest liability. New York has come to love him, and has seen what he's capable of. I think we're heading into the Eli Manning golden era -- his best years are now upon us and his improvement every year is noted, and i cant wait for him to prove everyone wrong this year and fully become the elite quarterback he is in everyones mind. Frankly, I am surprised that Brandon Jacobs isn’t a bit higher. I love Bradshaw but the hard hitting tone set by Jacobs is a crucial #1 in the 1-2 punch.

I like seeing the GM and HC up there too, way to give credit where its due in terms of vision, discipline, and focus.

Did you ever think in 2006 Eli Manning would be #1 on this list? Think about this — in every other NFC East market Eli Manning is known as the Giants biggest liability. New York has come to love him, and has seen what he’s capable of.

I think we’re heading into the Eli Manning golden era — his best years are now upon us and his improvement every year is noted, and i cant wait for him to prove everyone wrong this year and fully become the elite quarterback he is in everyones mind.

]]>