I’ll start with this: I never, ever want to call for someone to be fired. Never. There’s more to the person than the job. There’s a life. There’s a family. It’s not fair. I would never want anyone to call for my firing. So I’m not going to say that Bill Sheridan should be fired. It wouldn’t be fair. But, I will say, it could be time for a change. As you know, the Giants have vastly underperformed on defense since the injury to Kenny Phillips. We know CC Brown can’t cover, and has been a disaster. We know that the defense hasn’t gotten the same type of pressure that we’re used to.

We were spoiled with Steve Spagnoulo. He was a defensive genius. He was fiery. You felt safe with him. I didn’t think there would be much of a change when Sheridan took over. And maybe there hasn’t. We seem to forget that they were absolutely dominant against Tampa Bay and Oakland. But in games against contenders, the Giants D has not shown up.

I leave it to you. Should Sheridan be fired? Should he be kept? If they fire him, who should replace him? Discuss in the comments.