Shop for New York Giants gear at Fanatics.com

Giants Mock Draft

The draft is a little over a month away. It’s time to start mocking. Of course, this is the first of many. And, to start you off, this is only the first three rounds.

When you look at the Giants needs, there are a couple things that stand out: Middle Linebacker, Offensive Line, Defensive Line. That’s the three big ones. You can say secondary depth, but that’s a later round thing. The Giants need a middle linebacker.  I think they should go after Kirk Morrison, costing them a third round pick. But, he’s not on the Giants yet, so that’s the biggest need.

The Giants need some offensive lineman. There’s a couple ways of going about doing this. You can get a mauling right tackle, move Will Beatty over to left tackle, and slide David Diehl to left guard. You can get a premier left tackle, move Diehl to guard, and Beatty to right tackle. You can also get a stud guard, move Betty to left tackle, and Diehl to right tackle.

The last one is defensive tackle. With Chris Canty a question mark, and Jay Alford coming off of surgery, the Giants need a run-stopping defensive tackle.

The Giants will try to address these needs within the first three picks. I’m a proponent of drafting best player available. But, with needs that can be filled through the draft, the Giants should take the best player available of those three positions. If the best player available in the first round is a running back, you take the best available linebacker or lineman, and decide which one is better.

So, with that said, here it is.

WITH THE 15th PICK IN THE 2010 NFL DRAFT, THE NEW YORK GIANTS SELECT….

BRYAN BULAGA, OT, IOWA

I watched a lot of Bulaga this season, and in every game, I was impressed. He’s a left tackle, but I think he will be a stud at right tackle, where I would pencil him in for the 2010 season. Mauling, but quick. Great pass blocker, and improving run blocker. His prospect profile is here.

If the Giants draft Bulaga, the offensive line is a strength again. Diehl moves inside to left guard. Think about that: Diehl is a Pro Bowl left tackle. You move him inside to left guard? He’s an All-Pro. Will Beatty is your left tackle. Beatty was impressive last year in limited duty, and I think, as he continues to add weight and muscle, he will be a stud. The Giants rarely isolate the left tackle, so Beatty won’t have to do it alone. Bulaga is your right tackle. It’s possible that Bulaga starts at left tackle, but I think, coming straight out of college, going right to left tackle is a mistake. He could be there in 2011, and Beatty at right tackle. Your line is pretty good. The comparison I’ve seen about Bulaga is Michael Oher, who had an outstanding season for the Ravens, playing at left and right tackle. If Bulaga can do that, watch out.

WITH THE 46TH PICK IN THE 2010 NFL DRAFT, THE NEW YORK GIANTS SELECT…

ARTHUR JONES, DT, SYRACUSE

With the horrible play of Canty and Bernard, and the departure of Fred Robbins, a defensive tackle is needed. You can argue for Dan Williams in the first round ,but he’s more of a 3-4 tackle. Enter Arthur Jones. His profile is here. He’s a better run defender than a pass rusher, but I think that’s okay. Jay Alford is your pass rushing tackle. You don’t need Jones to be that guy. You need him to stop the run.

I think Jones is an awfully talented player–someone who could play right away. He played on a bad Syracuse team, and still played well. Surrounded by talent, he could put up huge numbers. He’s a smart player. Some say he’s better suited to be a 3-4 defensive end. There’s validity to that, and that may scare the Giants off. Still, as a 4-3 defensive tackle, he’s a heck of a talent, and someone who will produce in Blue.

WITH THE 76th PICK IN THE 2010 NFL DRAFT, THE NEW YORK GIANTS SELECT…

MICAH JOHNSON, ILB, KENTUCKY

Micah Johnson is a prototypical middle linebacker. Athletic, good tackler. His profile is here. The dude has sideline-to-sideline ability, something Antonio Pierce didn’t have. He’s pretty good in pass coverage, but not exceptional. He’s a great tackler.

Some say he could go in the second round, but after hurting his knee in Kentucky’s bowl game, he may fall into the third round, which would be a boon for the Giants. He played in a 3-4 in college, but I think he’s verstaile enough to play in a 4-3.

One problem: I think he’s not a starter right away. I think he contributes right away, especially on special teams, but he won’t start. Outside of Rolando McClain, there isn’t a middle linebacker who can start right away. That’s why the Giants should go after Morrison. I do think Johnson is a potential starter, and a very good one at that. The Giants have to decide if they want to stick with Jon Goff, or go after a vet.

That’s the first three rounds of the Giants draft. The address all their needs, and get players who can play right away. All three were productive, and from big schools. I like the way it plays out. Your thoughts?



Enjoyed this post?
Subscribe to Giants Gab via RSS Feed or E-mail and receive daily news updates from us!

Submit to Digg  Stumble This Story  Share on Twitter  Post on Facebook  Post on MySpace  Add to del.icio.us  Bark It Up  Submit to Reddit  Fave on Technorati

11 Responses to “Giants Mock Draft”

  1. alex says:

    I don’t think johnson will be able to start right away but spikes or spoon can mayb washington

  2. Micah Johnson had a bad combine and a bad Pro Day and on top of being injured at the start of the off-season program…it looks like his stock is slipping and might even be able to be had as late as the 5th or 6th round now, which I think would be an absolute steal. We’ll see what happens.

    I like him. Some don’t, but I still do.

    I love the Bryan Baluaga pick and am glad to see you’re on the bandwagon! Ive been touting an OL for awhile now becuase I think ultimately that will be the Best Player Available at 15 this year.

  3. Micah Johnson

    4.99 40 at the combine (TERRIBLE)

    4.84 at the Pro Day (Bad)

    But remember he got injured I think he’s faster than that. He plays much faster than that.

  4. Rey says:

    Offensive lineman with the first pick; excellent. Our second round pick should be a linebacker with the third round pick a defensive tackle.

  5. BIGPAPI360 says:

    I like this mock
    but maybe we should give up that 3rd round pick to the raiders for Kirk Morrison…..Im not sold on MICAH JOHNSON

  6. Serge Marinkovic MD says:

    I think if he is available along with Bulaga that Anthony Davis would be taken first. Why? Mean streak also translates into leadership on the OL. Although either will be a top notch OL with 2 years in the NFL. Stay away from Campbell a great athletic specimen but in interviews and tape I do not think he understands the game as well as he should and he appears on tape a little stiff while at the combine he had appreciable fluidity. Davis or Bulaga would make for an excellent draft.

  7. […] just did the first Giantsgab Mock Draft of the year . Check it out if you get the time. I also just posted the profile of CB Joe Haden   who might […]

  8. Sect 139 Veteran says:

    My perdiction is that the Giants trade Jax to get the 10th pick and draft Rolando McClain. Like you said he is the only one that can start rite away, plus speed at the MIK is essential in the Tampa 2 D. If you saw the Alabama pro day both Coughlin and Reese were there. They will have to give Jax there 1st & 4th round picks. Jax has the least amount of picks out of any team and plus they can get a player of need at 15, whether it be a DE or Earl Thomas. You heard it here first!

    • Steve B. says:

      I like McClain, and I am starting to believe that the Giants dont have to trade up for him.

      First off, he didnt have a blazing 40, which everyone knew that he wouldnt, so his stock didnt rise from that. It is also known publically now (they said teams knew) that he has Crohn’s disease. It really wont affect his football career because he had it all threw college and he is a 1st round pick.

      So if anything his stock didnt rise from the combine/pro day.

      The other thing is that Denver and Miami are the true real options for McClain. Miami just spent 43 million on Dansby, so it would be smart to look somewhere else in the first round, like rush LB.

      That leaves Denver, who looks like they are going to deal Marshall, so that would leave a void at WR, and Dez Bryant would make sense at pick 11.

      SF is not going to pick McClain, neither is seattle, so theoretically that would just leave the Giants to take him or skip him.

  9. BavaroBlue says:

    Not sure why you’re so high on Morrison. Did you watch him play much last year? He’s a decent player, but I don’t know if he’s worth a 3rd Rd pick in a deep draft. Fairly sure tackler, but he’s a liability in coverage. I don’t think number of tackles tells you all that much about a MLB…oftentimes it’s just the defensive scheme that dictates that.

    If McClain’s there, I take him. Otherwise, it’s a toss up between Dan Williams (if he’s there) and one of the O-lineman (Iuputi (who I love), Buluga or Williams). And there’s still a possibility that Spikes will be there in the 2nd round to take care of the MLB issue.

Leave a Reply