Shop for New York Giants gear at

Panthers Beat Giants 20-10

The preseason finally got under way, and as to be expected, it was sloppy and just a little bit boring as the Panthers beat the Giants 20-10

Giants started the game off in grand fashion, with Michael Boley intercepting a Jimmy Clausen pass and returning it  56 yards for the touchdown. Clausen settled down a bit, and threw an 18 yard strike to Greg Olsen.

The Giants and Panthers then exchanged field goals, with the Panthers hitting one more, and going into the half leading 13-10.

After a scoreless 3rd, Panthers scored in the 4th, as Derek Anderson connected with Kealoha Pilares on a 35 yard score, to make it 20-10.

First team defense saw some star performances but a pretty poor collective performance. Jason Pierre-Paul looked like a star, with two sacks and 7 tackles. Michael Boley returned an interception for a touchdown. Still, they let up too many big plays and too many missed tackles.

Some good performances were had by Alex Hall, Adrian Tracy and Brian Witherspoon. Witherspoon looked terrific at corner, and may now have the inside track to be the 4th corner.

Aaron Ross looked lost out there, missing tackles and getting beat in coverage. Ross is going to have to be an important part of this defense. With the Giants planning to move Thomas inside to safety on third downs, Ross needs to hold his own as a corner. If not, Giants could be in serious trouble.

First team offense did nothing. Jacobs and Bradshaw had a few nice runs, but they just didn’t move the ball. 2nd team was a bit better. Hixon had a bunch of nice catches, and Devin Thomas played well. Rosenfels looked pretty good, played well enough to be the backup. Ryan Perriloux impressed with a strong arm.  DJ Ware didn’t distinguish himself as the third running back, but no one else moved ahead of him.

I think Eli summed up the offense best:

“We didn’t get off to a great start. We were never able to get into a great rhythm. We made a couple of mental mistakes.”

Special teams was ugly. Other than good punting performances from Dodge and Weatherford, it was not pretty. Coverage was awful. Missed tackles all the way around. Only good play was by Victor Cruz, who made a nice tackle. Tynes missed two field goals, had one blocked, and came up hurt on one. The Giants are calling it a thigh contusion. You would think, after Tynes took a helmet to his thigh. Ouch.  Jernigan did nothing on returns.

For those interested, Cam Newton showed off his big arm. Not always accurate, but incredible strength. He has all the talent. Needs time, of course, but he has a chance to get there.

No rookies really stood out. Tyler Sash got beat on a few plays, but had a forced fumble. Austin, Jernigan, Brewer and the linebackers didn’t really do anything. But it’s early.

It’s the first game of preseason, so you can’t expect the world. It sure looked like the first game of preseason. Shaky. Out of sync. Poor fundamentals. Good individual performances gives us hope. But lack of tackling, and so many missed tackles, are very concerning. You never want to put too much stock in preseason games. But, you look for trends. And trends from last year continued. Missed tackles, poor special teams coverage, drives with nothing doing on offense, those are concerning trends.

Enjoyed this post?
Subscribe to Giants Gab via RSS Feed or E-mail and receive daily news updates from us!

Submit to Digg  Stumble This Story  Share on Twitter  Post on Facebook  Post on MySpace  Add to  Bark It Up  Submit to Reddit  Fave on Technorati

6 Responses to “Panthers Beat Giants 20-10”

  1. PC says:

    Giants suck 7-9 if we are lucky!!! way to go Reese!!!

  2. Jason C. says:

    JPP, Boley, Hixon, Thomas, Witherspoon and the punters deserved to get ice cream after this one. Everyone else was mediocre to terrible.
    Ross missed more tackles in this game than a respectable TEAM should by their bye week. Sash in coverage is scary, I think Deon Grant gets a phone call tomorrow. Tynes was bad, and then he got hurt. And so on and so on.

    Things for next week:
    Run about 300 defensive screenpass drills a day at practice.
    Have Cruz, a wide receiver, teach the rest of the team how to tackle.
    Offensive line was pretty bad, but I do expect that to improve with time (hopefully there’s enough time before Sept. 11).
    Special Teams, in every aspect (except, dare I say, the punting) needs improvement (Reynaud ALMOST broke one towards the end, but then he realized he was Reynaud).

    Overall it’s only the first preseason game, and the important thing, no serious injuries (got scared when I saw the slick field).
    Let’s get cracking into pre-week 2, Chicago got sacked 9 times by Buffalo, so should be fun.

  3. Eric says:

    We had Phillip rivers! What did we do?!!!!!!!! Another season of Eli manning duck and chuck football!.

  4. Casey says:

    Matt Dodge is starting to show that leg and consistency he did in college. He deserves the roster spot and will be best for the franchise. He will only grow. Nice job Matt!

  5. Big Daddy says:

    This team looked like a bunch of rusty nails. I saw a lot of good things to build on. But Coughlin knows what he has to do, a lot of tackling drills. Lets see if these things are fixed by next game.

    This is one reason why you need 4 preseason games.

    Yeah Rivers is the answer to every problem the Giants have and will ever have. After every loss just say if we only had Rivers. I doubt people who say that were saying that after we won the super bowl…LMAO.

  6. Eric says:

    our d was mostly responsible for that. you think Phillip rivers could not have scored 17 points against the pats d??

Leave a Reply